| 2020 |
Joe Clinton, Dominican |
| 2019 |
Charles Marquardt, Molloy |
| 2018 |
Gerald Holmes, Bloomfield |
| 2017 |
Tobin Anderson, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 2016 |
Tobin Anderson, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 2015 |
Tobin Anderson, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 2014 |
Steve Hayn, Dowling |
| 2013 |
Joe Clinton, Dominican |
| 2012 |
Chris Casey, LIU-Post |
| 2011 |
Gerald Holmes, Bloomfield |
| 2010 |
David DeFerrari, Felician |
| 2009 |
Tim Cluess, C.W. Post |
| 2008 |
Tim Cluess, C.W. Post |
| 2007 |
Sal Lagano, NYIT |
| 2006 |
James Cosgrove, Adelphi |
| 2005 |
Gerald Holmes, Bloomfield & James Cosgrove, Adelphi |
| 2004 |
Sal Lagano, NYIT |
| 2003 |
Tom Galeazzi, C.W. Post |
| 2002 |
Jim Ferry, Adelphi |
| 2001 |
Jim Ferry, Adelphi |
| 2000 |
Jim Ferry, Adelphi |
| 1999 |
Jim Harter, Pace |
| 1998 |
Mark Corino, Caldwell |
| 1997 |
Steve Clifford, Adelphi & Dennis O'Donnell, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 1996 |
Joe Clinton, Dominican |
| 1995 |
Jim O'Connor, Adelphi |
| 1994 |
Dennis O'Donnell, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 1993 |
Jim O'Connor, Adelphi |
| 1992 |
Darrell Halloran, Pace |
| 1991 |
Tom Galeazzi, C.W. Post |
| 1990 |
Darrell Halloran, Pace |
| 1989 |
Steve Kelly, Dominican |
| 1988 |
Dave Possinger, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 1987 |
Dave Possinger, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 1986 |
Tom Galeazzi, C.W. Post & Dave Possinger, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 1985 |
Tom Galeazzi, C.W. Post |
| 1984 |
Dave Possinger, St. Thomas Aquinas |