| 2020 |
Ryan Turell, Yeshiva |
| 2019 |
Sam Toney, New Jersey City |
| 2018 |
Chimaechi Ekekeugbor, Baruch & Sam Toney, New Jersey City |
| 2017 |
Thomas Bonacum, Ramapo & Frank Schettino, Staten Island |
| 2016 |
Will Fonseca, Staten Island |
| 2015 |
Will Fonseca, Staten Island |
| 2014 |
Javae King-Gilchrist, William Paterson |
| 2013 |
A.J. Matthews, Farmingdale |
| 2012 |
A.J. Matthews, Farmingdale |
| 2011 |
Jonathan Jones, Kean |
| 2010 |
Marcel Esonwune, York |
| 2009 |
Richard Jean-Baptiste, Brooklyn & Damien Santana, Farmingdale |
| 2008 |
Richard Jean-Baptiste, Brooklyn |
| 2007 |
Ahmad Mobsy, Ramapo |
| 2006 |
Gian Paul Gonzalez, Montclair State |
| 2005 |
Amin Wright, Ramapo |
| 2004 |
Samar Battle, New Jersey City |
| 2003 |
Charles Ransom, Ramapo |
| 2002 |
David Paul, Staten Island |
| 2001 |
Horace Jenkins, William Paterson |
| 2000 |
Horace Jenkins, William Paterson |
| 1999 |
Sean Bradley, U.S. Merchant Marine |
| 1998 |
Sean Bradley, U.S. Merchant Marine |
| 1997 |
Ira Nicholson, Mount St. Vincent |
| 1996 |
Clarence Pierce, New Jersey Institute of Technology |
| 1995 |
Clarence Pierce, New Jersey Institute of Technology |
| 1994 |
Shawn McCartney, Hunter |
| 1993 |
Jose Rodriguez, Hunter |
| 1992 |
Jose Rodriguez, Hunter & Fred Drains, Kean |
| 1991 |
Herman Alston, Kean |
| 1990 |
Kevin D'Arcy, U.S. Merchant Marine |
| 1989 |
Rob Roesch, Staten Island |
| 1988 |
Rob Roesch, Staten Island |
| 1987 |
Johnny Mayers, New Jersey City & Terry Tarpey, New York University |
| 1986 |
Steve Wilder, New Jersey City |
| 1985 |
Robert McNamee, U.S. Merchant Marine Academy |
| 1984 |
Mark Ward, Manhattanville |
| 1983 |
James Wilson, John Jay |
| 1982 |
Fred Oglesby, Pace |
| 1981 |
Gary Carter, Monmouth |