| 2020 |
Elliot Steinmetz, Yeshiva |
| 2019 |
Marc Brown, New Jersey City |
| 2018 |
Chuck McBreen, Ramapo |
| 2017 |
Chuck McBreen, Ramapo |
| 2016 |
Rich Micallef, Brooklyn |
| 2015 |
John Alesi, Baruch |
| 2014 |
Jeff Charney, Purchase |
| 2013 |
Marc Brown, New Jersey City |
| 2012 |
Jose Rebimbas, William Paterson |
| 2011 |
Bob Campbell, Western Connecticut & Chuck McBreen, Ramapo |
| 2010 |
Jeff Charney, Purchase & Jose Rebimbas, William Paterson |
| 2009 |
Ray Rankis, Baruch |
| 2008 |
Erik Smiles, Farmingdale State |
| 2007 |
Joe Nesci, New York University |
| 2006 |
Jose Rebimbas, William Paterson |
| 2005 |
Chuck McBreen, Ramapo |
| 2004 |
Charles Brown, New Jersey City |
| 2003 |
Chuck McBreen, Ramapo |
| 2002 |
Bob Campbell, Western Connecticut |
| 2001 |
Bill Lange, U.S. Merchant Marine |
| 2000 |
Joe Maniaci, St. Joseph's-LI |
| 1999 |
Jose Rebimbas, William Paterson |
| 1998 |
Mike Brown, Hunter |
| 1997 |
Ron St. John, York |
| 1996 |
Chuck Mancuso, Mount St. Vincent |
| 1995 |
Jim Catalano, New Jersey Institute of Technology |
| 1994 |
Joe Nesci, New York University |
| 1993 |
Ray Amalbert, Hunter & Joe Nesci, New York University |
| 1992 |
Charles Brown, Jersey City State & Joe Nesci, New York University |
| 1991 |
Todd Meyer, Ramapo |
| 1990 |
Charles Brown, Jersey City State & Bob Campbell, Western Connecticut |